I've been managing automation component budgets for a mid-sized packaging company for about six years — roughly $180,000 in cumulative PLC spending. After comparing quotes from a dozen distributors and tracking every invoice, I've learned that the cheapest PLC quote is rarely the cheapest overall. Here are the questions I wish someone had answered clearly when I started.
From the outside, it looks like FX5U is the entry-level option and Q series is for complex lines. The reality is, FX5U now handles quite a bit of mid-range motion and networking. I once spec'd a Q series for a packaging machine, and we ended up using maybe 40% of its I/O capacity. That was overkill — the FX5U would have covered it for half the hardware cost. (Should mention: check scan time and axis count carefully, not just I/O count.)
The base module price is just the start. Total cost includes: programming software license (GX Works3 for FX5U, GX Works2 for Q), spare parts buffer (we keep one CPU module per critical line), and emergency shipping. In Q2 2024, when we switched distributors, I compared 6 quotes. One vendor charged $450 for 'free setup' — a hidden configuration fee. The total cost difference between lowest and highest quote was 23% — mostly in accessories and freight. I built a TCO spreadsheet after that.
I have mixed feelings about refurbished PLCs. On one hand, I've bought three refurbished FX3U modules that ran flawlessly for two years — saved about $800 each. On the other, one 'as-is' Q02CPU failed after four months, and the re-diagnostic cost ate up all the savings. The way I see it, buy refurbished only from a vendor that offers a 1-year warranty and documents test results. Otherwise, new is cheaper in the long run.
The most frustrating part of PLC programming costs: rework. You'd think clear specs would prevent it, but I've seen $1,200 redo bills because the engineer misinterpreted a single line about safety interlocks. What finally helped was mandating a structured comment template in GX Works — cuts handover time by maybe 30%. Also, creating a standard library of reusable function blocks for common tasks (like conveyor control) saved us roughly 15 hours per new project.
People assume online tutorials are enough for FX5U programming. What they don't see is the hidden cost: trial-and-error development time. I ignored the official training once — wasted three weeks debugging a positioning module because I didn't know about the dedicated SFC limitations. The $1,500 training course would have paid for itself in that one project alone. In my opinion, invest in training for the first engineer; after that, internal knowledge transfer works.
The vendor failure in March 2023 changed how I think about backup planning. One critical deadline missed because a common Q series module was backordered — suddenly redundancy didn't seem like overkill. We implemented a '3-quote, 1-stock' policy: always have a single spare unit on hand for each PLC series. That policy cut our emergency-purchase expenses by 40% that year. Also, never assume all modules are pin-compatible — I once ordered an FX3U-32MT thinking it would swap with an FX3U-32MR — the transistor vs relay output difference caused a $450 rewire.